Pureluck

I am in the air on which broadhead to use now. Which would you guys use and why?

Dont know if a poll will show up or not but here are my four choices

1. Magnus Stinger

2. Slick Trick

3. Hellrazor

4. PhatHead SOB

__________________
McPherson Monster 63lbs 28in 297fps PileDriver Hunter 350

yotekilla

All are good heads. The slick tricks have the advantage of changable blades. All have good track records. I would try the Mangus, they have been around a while and I have heard a lot of good things about them. I'm gonna try the 2 blade bloodrunners, I have also been reading up on Bass Pros redhead gator expandable. Seems rage decided to reinvent the wheel, but I hear the gators are more liked by people that have shot both, they are cheap to.

__________________
PSE EVO 65lb. 29" draw Golt tip pro hunters 100gr slick tricks 380gr arrow 300fps.

Fabbri

slick trick
'couse they flight like field point and u could change the blades
better than slick trick I could suggest just the G5 montec
but... between the one u asked.... slick trick

Fabrizio

BigBuck-A-Roo

Hellrazor! And if I had to try another it would be the Buzzcuts or the RFA Phoenix

__________________
PSE BOW MADNESS 32 at 66.5 lbs 28 inch draw and Nap Hellrazors

acc371

I don't think changeable blades are an advantage. At least my wallet doesn't agree!
Couple of swipes of a smooth stone is allot cheaper than replacement blades.
Stingers have a lifetime warranty.
I went looking for 125gr Phatheads this year. Couldn't find them. 2 Pro Shops(Papes), Cabelas, Bass Pro, GanderMtn., Lancaster, Keystone.

mudslinger

All you have listed are very good heads, but I am going to add another just because. Smoke Ramcats!

__________________
09 HCA Speed Pro 29" 70# Gold Tip XT Hunter 28" @560 grains Smoke Ramcats!

RAZORHEAD

and i love em. I killed my first deer this year with a bow using a hellrazor but they will not fly with these stingers... Cant wait to try them on some meat.

TPjeep

Slick Trick, fly with points, deadly on animals

ricksmathew

Slick Tricks. Fly great, tough, sharp and leave devastating holes!

coiloil37

Might want to try a couple of them. I've shot deer with stingers and hellrazors. I've also got some slick tricks. I think all three fly awesome but if your tuned so does almost everything. The best blood trail I saw this year was with a hellrazor. I also like that you can easily resharpen them. I also shot a deer and a coyote with stingers this year. I only found one arrow and the head was severly damaged, tip was folded over, blades were very dull/damaged. Didn't really impress me but they have a warranty. So maybe the snuffer ss would be another one to consider. You get the ease of resharpening, coupled with a lifetime warranty. Basically you buy them and until you lose them, there are no reoccurring costs.

tigerhunter

All of these are excellent, and I mean excellent heads. I have not killed a deer with the Phathead, but the others have done an outstanding job for me. I chose Slick Tricks because they fly true with my field points(and I don't mean like the bodacious claim of flying like your field points which means, they group well ONCE you tune for them in many instances) without tuning. Also, this past season, I killed a doe with a 17 yard quartering away shot. I hit her right behind her back right rib and the arrow passed clean through...Big deal I know, but it had to pass through her brisket in order to do so. The head was in outstanding condition. I did not get to take many pictures, and especially of the the brisket(I had already cut through it with the shears), but I will post the ones I have. Simply devastating.
Well, I said I would but I can only find the one...not the guts hanging out behind her ribs. She had been shot 15 minutes earlier and the coyotes had already gotten to her.

Attached Images

100MEDIA_IMAG0041.jpg (11.7 KB, 37 views)

__________________
Athens Factory Staff Shooter
Athens Buck Commander

CallMaker

I picked the Magnus as it is the only one I have used, and with good results. My 2nd choice would be a Trick but a Razor Trick rather than a Slick Trick.

elkslayer4x5

Personally I'm a 3 blade Muzzy guy, and have no trouble getting them tuned to my setup, just swaped rests, took less than 30 minutes and the Muzzys where cutting vanes off the field points already in the bullseye.

__________________
EastOutfitters 2 Martin 06 Slayer 63# & 55#; QuikTune 3000 Micro, HHA OL 5519. 04 Cougar Elite, QT 1000 All C nitrous shoot thru

Bowhuntr64

All great heads that you mentioned. However, I cannot imagine a better all round head than the ST Standard. You will be hard pressed to find a better balance of surface cut (2"), flight, durability, and penetration. If you add in price as a criteria, finding a better one will be even more difficult.

bubinga

All good heads, I have had good luck with the ST and Stingers. Shoot the Stingers most the time these days. BTW if you are having to shoot a certain head to get them to fly with your fieldpoints, then you either are not spintesting and truing your broadheads or more likely you bow needs proper tuning. Paper tuning is just a start.